Find the sample essay (pp. 245 - 46?) responding to the
New York Times assignment. Read it and criticize it, noting both its effective and ineffective qualities. We'll discuss the essay during the second half of class on Wednesday, so what you're really trying to do (I hope) is generate something to say during the discussion of the essay.
Think in terms of all the positive qualities you might expect in an argumentative, multiple-source essay. Does the essay have a precise, restricted, and unified argumentative point of view. Do the paragraphs develop that thesis? Do its arguments support the thesis. Are those arguments developed with analysis and detailed evidence?
Cordially,
Tom Burns
P.S. Have you completed Blog Assignment #7 yet? If not, please do so ASAP. We'll talk about it during the first half of Wednesday's class.